School is a waste of time

VAUGHN TURNBULL
Opinions Writer

I’m in my last year of university at the U of S and I have slowly become closer and closer to dropping out. Is it because I’m a lazy deadbeat? Maybe, but there’s a little more to it than that. 

I went into university with great expectations. I was an honour-roll student four years straight in high school and was excited at the amazing learning experience of college. But my three years at the U of S have proven to be nothing but disappointing. What I was expecting was enlightened professors with amazing insight and knowledge, interesting classes and fun experiences. I didn’t get any of these.

Professors

“Those who can’t do, teach.” This is a joke I heard a few years ago but it’s no joke at the U of S. Most professors have been in university since age 18 and have never actually gone into the “real world” they so often reference. If you were successful in your field, you would be out making lots of money at it instead of teaching moody young adults. We are being taught for the most part by people who are real world failures, not the ideal people to be instructed by, in my opinion. 

Some professors have had jobs outside of teaching, but with these individuals, one must ask why they are now teaching if they could succeed in real life. Perhaps they tried and failed after a while, or maybe they just wanted the easy $100,000 a year with a nice pension. They are either quitters or lazy — shining examples for impressionable young minds.

One issue with some (but not all) professors is arrogance. The attitude of commander-in-chief that some professors have is laughable. It’s even more fun when they have the “What do you know? You’re just a kid,” approach to students. We pay their salaries and they are condescending in return. Smashing.

My favourite is if you question a prof’s statement or disagree with something they are saying. You better not bring it up in front of the class because that could hurt their feelings, which in turn will hurt your marks for the rest of the term. Oh, they’ll deny that to the death, but it’s true; profs need their egos stroked or their world comes crashing down faster than a house of cards in a hurricane. 

Textbooks

 
95 per cent of textbooks suck. It’s not a secret. Either they’re using data from the ’80s or it seems like they were written by someone who has never had any social interaction before. There’s also the fact that they are boring; there’s way too much information just for the sake of filling pages. I guess the longer the book is, the more they can charge for it.

My favourite part of textbooks is the new edition each year with the chapter order switched around or three new pages added on. But the edition from the year before is obsolete, so don’t even think about using it. And forget about trying to sell your old texts to students, because they need the most current information to ensure a good learning experience. Ha!

Textbooks are either written by some knob from the States (or sometimes the U.K. — how exotic!) or they’re done by U of S professors. When you have a class that has a text written by the prof teaching the class, suddenly buying the text is a matter of utter importance. Cha-ching! Royalty cheque rolling in.

The texts are terrible but, despite this, probably half of the professors in the school teach directly from the text. Why am I going to class if you’re just going to regurgitate the text to me in verbal form? Because I am a good little worker bee and I do as I’m told? Or I hope to get something besides a boring read for my $600 class? Too bad I just get a book read to me in monotone. It’s like getting Microsoft Narrator to speak a textbook with some dull PowerPoint slides to boot. 

Money

I’m paying $6,000 a year for classes, a few hundred for “services” and around $1,000 for books per year. Scam! We’re getting rung drier than a ShamWow on an infomercial. For rezzies and others from out of town or living on their own you can add the cost of food (or meal plans) and housing onto the whole bundle as well. Students need to work full time year round to cover these costs. A lot of us can’t though, so we rack up student loans (which won’t be easy to pay off with a history degree. Sorry, it’s true).

Once you pay all this cash for a nice piece of paper and some letters after your name you get a nice, high-paying job, right?

With a lot of degrees obtained at the U of S, you may as well have invested your tuition money in Enron. With the money we spend here they should have a job lined up for us upon exit, but we just get a kick in the pants and begin a long, difficult job hunt. 

Think about what you’re paying for each class. In Term 2 there are approximately 24 lectures per course. With the course costing approximately $600 and the text at, oh say $100, that’s nearly $30 per class. For about an hour long lecture, is it really worth the money? For 30 bucks you could go see two movies at Galaxy and even get snacks for each! Even if one of the movies sucks, you’re still getting more entertainment value than a prof reading some PowerPoint slides.

Oh, sure, sure, but school isn’t about entertainment. It’s about learning and education. Let’s not lie to ourselves; there’s not much of that going on. So if we aren’t learning we should at least be entertained. And as fun as it is watching documentaries when the prof is too lazy to give a lecture; it’s just not worth the moolah. 

Social life

Remember all those epic college parties in the movies? Lies! Granted these were hyped up, Hollywood versions of college, they are way more fun than real school parties. There are a few parties hosted by various groups within the university, but basically all of them are either a fundraiser for some stupid student club or just a gathering of a ton of students in a situation no different than a bar.

Take LB5Q for instance: Pay us $10 so you can take a bus to a field on a cold September night and pay $5 a drink and have mediocre local bands play while you get muddy and cold and wet (not in a good way). Oh, and add three thousand loud, rowdy drunks to bump into you, spill their drinks on you and throw up in your general vicinity; sounds like a stupendous time.

Keep in mind that I’m not an elitist; I don’t want a wine and cheese art gallery event, but the parties that go on are pretty weak. Sure, they allow beer gardens to be set up for the first week of school in the bowl, but that just nets them a wad of cash from overpriced beer sales and, let’s face it, they need something to con us into not leaving right then and there.

Social life should be a fundamental part of the college experience. At the U of S it usually consists of lame massive parties or fundraisers, house parties (just like high school!) and bonding in common areas like the Reading Room where we can complain about our shitty profs, assignments and classes. Move aside Animal House, party over here! 

So why do we do it? Nothing better to do, I suppose. I think a lot of students have an idealized view of university and how they’ll get their nice jobs after graduating and be set. Wake up. Lawyers, doctors, accountants and other professionals might have a nice career path ahead of them, but most graduates can expect a flashy starting salary below $40,000. I wish you luck buying a house outside the ghetto with that minimal chunk of change.

And those aforementioned professionals can probably look forward to a repetitive job for a big corporation with the light of retirement at the end of the tunnel. Secondary education creates cookie cutter people who haven’t learned much and wasted time and money only to have a boring career until retirement or death. If that is what all the U of S recruitment advertisements said, there might be fewer applicants.

- -
Sheaf contributor Alex Ferwerda has written a response to this article. It was printed in the Jan. 14 issue of the Sheaf and can be viewed HERE.


Social Networking

Follow the Sheaf on Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.

  • Grad student

    I am a grad student at the university and I have TA’ed or TA many undergrad labs (at least 12 courses). In every lab, I try my best to improve my teaching and make it a positive and knowledge enriching activity for the students (I see my peer grads doing the same too). Reading the TA evaluations I find that students often just criticize you very badly; there are very few students who are appreciative of the time, effort, and enthusiasm shown on the side of the instructors. That being said, how many students actually bother to do instructor/TA evaluations? How do you expect a prof to improve their teaching skills if you don’t give any feedback?
    Often you see many students texting, listening to music, sleeping, checking social networks etc in classes. How do you expect someone to give a rockstar entertainment if someone is not listening to you? And did one expect to be entertained while getting into university? I didn’t know that! University isn’t a place where you just get knowledge; its a place where one learns how to find knowledge, its not spoon feeding. Its a place for realizing your potential and making best use of it, its a place for respecting other people and their qualities and trying to make oneself a better, useful individual to the society (at least that’s the way I see about it).
    Universities are moving towards getting most out of profs, and the profs have a very hard time balancing research, teaching, and professional activities. Most profs are pressurized into securing high/many research funds, and have been advised to spend more time (70%)on research and revenue generation for universities. Also, more classes are becoming online. Thus many want-to-be-prof grad students are lacking opportunities for teaching classes/giving lectures. Why are we losing these regular face-to-face courses, people like yourself who just complain and want education offered to them at “subsidized costs”. However, this removes away the chance for active learning and the element of immediate feedback during the learning process. So now the question is do we really need universities if we have a generation who cares less?
    Regarding profs arrogance – I find that many of the younger students are always in a hurry. They need readymade answers, easy exams, easy assignments, open book exams etc. The profs aren’t being arrogant, instead they’re trying to test your skills and thinking and in that attempt create opportunities for self-learning/exploration. Also, how many of the students engage in active learning (asking questions, arguing profs views/thoughts) in a class room?
    Dude, how did you get your honors? Seems like you’re super brilliant and can learn anything all by yourself! What are doing at the U of S? Why didn’t you try getting into Harvard, Cambridge, or Oxford? I think the profs have been very generous to pass a party-hopper like you, seriously! Your arrogance seems like you can do better than all the profs! If that’s the case, go show yourself that you can do a better job at just about everything! Go prove yourself to us!
    And just so you know – profs don’t make a million bucks! Most start at $50K, and that after 2-3 years of a post-doctoral. I know in my field, the number of faculty openings is less than 3-5/year for the whole of Canada!
    Also to add: I don’t know how Sheaf decided to select this article for publication? I read Sheaf to relax and learn about things happening around the univ. Now would I read the Sheaf for that, hmmm… probably not. You just spoiled all my mood!

  • Sarah

    From Rate Your Students:

    (Sigh)
    I’ve tried to fight this. I have a picture of a certain comic on my desk to restrain me in precisely these circumstances….

    The remainder of this comment has been removed due to abusive language.

  • Kring

    If you think your subsidized life of attending lectures and hanging out in beer gardens is bad, wait until you graduate and need to work for a living! The horrors of campus will not begin to compare to the horrors of the cubicle, the rent payments, the unpleasant people on the city streets.

    By the way, many real-world people are real-world failures as well, on some level, because they stifled their dreams. You’d be surprised how many wished they could still be in college, writing poetry, living the life of the mind, going on long trips abroad… (you know, the things professors do…)

    College isn’t a life-long meal ticket. Your success or failure is in fact your own responsibility.

    For instance, if you applied for a job at my organization, I would Google your name, find this essay, and immediately push for you to be turned down on the basis of immaturity and lack of writing/logic skills. FYI.

  • Vaughn

    Hello folks, thanks for the tasteful replies and personal attacks. Classy. Evidently my half humour half sad truth article goes unappreciated, but I’m glad I seemingly wasted a page of the Sheaf which you fund with your student fees and gave you something to do besides “learn.” It amazes me how riled up educated individuals can get over such trivial writing done when I was bored one night. I’ll be graduating with great distinction this year and be out of your way. Cheers.
    >>Vaughn Turnbull

  • A.S.tudent

    I’d say I’d have to agree with Vaughn. It’s not because we’re lazy, it’s because we’re ambitious and want to be independent of the very thing society demands.

    A Phd is not an education degree, granted I’m sure it’s hard work, after all, I am planning on getting mine one day, but I still think I lack teaching skills. Therefore I will do, but I will not teach.

    As for costs, since I don’t have time to work a full time job during the academic year, I have to work a bottom of the totem pole oilfield job in the summer in order to pay for only half of a year. I am a 20-year-old female, I’d like to see a handful of my bad professors spend a summer doing what I do, and I’ll be completely honest in saying it is one of the shittiest jobs anyone could encounter.

    I have been increasingly wondering why I am still in school getting a business degree… and the truth hurts, social sciences just don’t pay.

    Keep up the good work, Vaughn!

  • Devin

    First of all, if anyone is going to call out Vaughn Turnbull and curse him out, post your full name, so everyone can search for you on the net also. You have someone that wrote an article using his right to free speech to state HIS opinion of what school entitles, which may be different than your own, without hiding behind a computer screen. I see the issue from both sides of the argument, whether school is a waste or not. But, since everything has been so negative about the original article, I’m going to join the “bad guys” for this debate.

    “Oh, I’m SO sorry that you might have to earn less than $40,000 a year right out of college. Some of us can actually live very comfortably on a salary in that range, and are content with the idea that we might have to work to earn more than that.”

    “Maybe it’s different in Canada, but we “knobs” here in the States…”
    SARAH (from Rate Your Students), you’re right, it is different in Canada than in the States. Making $40 000/yr in the states right now is enough to live comfortably in your cheap 8000 sq ft house. Where we are living in Canada, a 800 sq ft house, in a pretty shitty neighbourhood is roughly $280-295 000. So, the $35 000 you make from your history degree may not be that comfortable where the writer is from. The majority of our brilliant professors go to your country because they are offered a lot more money than the shitty $100 000/yr that our Canadian college can afford to pay them.

    Your elitist attitude is quite apparent because you personally attack someone because they have different opinions than you. Your bashing of Vaughn’s writing is a little hypocritical seeing as you quoted every single word in his writing. When writing, you don’t quote a whole journal you are drawing your resources from. If you were a better writer than him as well, your quotes would have been quite limited as EVERYONE who is posting has read his article.

  • Kedves

    As a university instructor, I say, “Put those insights into action, young man. Quit now! You’re right: grown-up life sucks. Why participate in its so-called benefits? Who are all those people to tell you how to live? The sooner you go your own unique way, the sooner you will find excellence. Didn’t that dude say that all the world’s a party and all the men and women merely wanderers in search of a fresh keg? There you go. Please don’t transfer to my school, though. We can’t handle the truth.”

  • Ellie

    Nice pension? $100,000k salary? Easy work? Sign me up!

    Here’s the thing. I AM a professor. My salary is barely over 40% of your imaginary figure. My department head and the dean don’t even approach $100,000. That “pension” is actually a 401k where the majority of the money being invested is deducted from my already small paycheck.

    And don’t even get me started on “easy.”

    How easy do you think it is to give 100% in the classroom, and then an additional 100% in institutional service, and another 100% to my research/personal projects? That’s right. As a professor, I have one low salary, a crappy retirement plan, and three full-time jobs. If I don’t do well in the classroom (as reported on your student evaluations), I don’t get tenure. If I don’t publish and present at conferences, I don’t get tenure. And if I don’t serve on committees and task forces and advise students I also don’t get tenure.

    Students, you don’t see 80% of what us professors do. You have no idea how many hours we spend re-reading the textbook at 7:00 a.m. to prepare for class even though we’ve assigned this same reading for the past five semesters, calling agents to book speakers for the college lecture series during our lunch break, meeting with students all afternoon to discuss homework or scheduling problems, attending 4:30 meetings to brainstorm about how to prevent you from transferring or dropping out, and going home to grade papers at our kitchen tables for a few hours in the evening. This is my typical day. Sound easy? Because to me, it sounds like I deserve more money. Sure, I get summers off, but I make up those hours during the other 9 months of the year.

  • Ellie

    OK, correction. My salary is in US dollars. I didn’t realize this was a Canadian college. However, my salary still doesn’t approach $100,000 Canadian dollars (though the disparity is less than I had originally presumed), I do still work 3 jobs for the price of one, and Vaughn still doesn’t get it.

  • Deby

    Wow, you all take this so seriously! School is hard and real life is hard too. I am 45 years old and a gramma…put yourself in my shoes. I am not at University to socialize and bash the academic system. I would be glad to start out with $40,000 a year. It is way more than I am getting now, and NO I am not getting paid to go to school by the tax payers!
    Vaughn has right to speak his mind..so does everyone. Ethically speaking he is not hurting anyone by doing so. An opinion article is just that an opinion.
    I struggle everyday to make something of my school time..I am doing homework and reading my textbooks seven days a week. I wish I had time to partake in the social life.
    I am sorry if the article offended some of you but you all need to take a step back and think about what the article really says. Vaughn is going to finish school and he is going to graduate with honors, kudos to him. Worry about yourselves and not what some kid who had some free time and the ability to fluff some feathers!

  • lilbuddy :D

    For all you who said Vaughn is an idiot, Vaughn is smarter than fricken google. If i need an answer to absolutely anything I can ask him and he’ll know. No word of a lie. Quite impressive. And any professors that beaked, well you’re professors.. which means the article personally attacked you and so now you feel insecure about your careers. Not a legit reason to post long-ass comments on here defending yourselves. I mean you can, but doesn’t gain you points.

  • The Sheaf

    Thank you all for your comments, but this discussion has gone on too long. Comments are now closed.

    Sincerely,
    TheSheaf.com administrator